How to Create Craftsman-Style Door Trim

Jan 25, 2021

How to Create Craftsman-Style Door Trim

Jan 25, 2021

This post contains affiliate links. This means I may earn a small commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you. Read my disclosure here.

how to skip painting mistakes
making painting mistakes

Originally published April 18, 2019. Updated January 25, 2021.

Today I’m sharing an updated post on our Craftsman-style door trim, which was prompted by readers who asked for more detail. This Craftsman-style trim is one of my favorite details in our 1965 ranch. It takes us awhile to update trim through the entire house, but it’s totally worth the wait for a more high-end look. Here’s how we’ve created our Craftsman-style door trim.

craftsman style door trim

Jump to These Sections:

Old Doors Before Update
Measurements of New Craftsman-Style Trim
Best Trim Products – Wood or MDF
How to Adjust Trim for Hinges and Strike Plates
Final Reveal + Project Sources



Old Doors Before Craftsman-Style Door Trim Update

Here’s where we started, with original hollow doors and simple molding. Not a great photo, but you can get the idea. We actually swapped out a bunch of these doors for damaged ones at our first house. (We owned both houses for a time, while we finished work on the first and moved into the second.) I painted the old doors white, to match the trim and unify the interior, and they looked pretty nice. Painting is almost always the most affordable update, but since we needed to replace some anyway, we invested in upgraded doors for the new house (similar). I’m so happy we did. They make such a difference in the look and feel of this home.

Check out our house in this post: A “Work in Progress” Home Tour

old hollow wood doors and simple casing


Craftsman-Style Door Trim to Match + Our Measurements

**All product sources are listed at the end of the post.**

When we first moved in, I sorted through Pinterest to get ideas for door trim, or casing. There are some great ideas out there! What appeals to me the most is a stacked look on top using a few pieces of molding. We have enough room above the rough openings to add interesting trim without crowding the space.

rough doors with no casing
similar 3-panel door | Schlage Latitude lever

Read More: 60+ Modern Black Door Hardware Ideas

Our first step was to head to Home Depot and buy a few pieces of trim in different sizes. Next, we held them up in different combinations above the doors to figure out what looks best.

Since we have 1×4 running vertically along the sides of the doors, we worked around that. After looking at the trim in different combinations, we chose some smaller pieces to add detail. We both like a header with boards like this, but all painted white:

mockup of putting trim pieces together for door casing

Now, here’s the thing. The dimensions are all flexible. We started with 1×4 boards for the sides and top. The dimensions of the smaller pieces matter less, because it’s all about how they work together. I’ve posted a photo below with exact sizes we’re using, but honestly, it’s doesn’t matter. I just wanted a wider piece on the very top, so it would cover the 1×4, and a smaller “skinny” piece under the horizontal 1×4.

craftsman style door trim measurements

For our project, the widest pieces on top overhang the vertical door casing by 1 inch on each side. The 1×4 on top is just 1/4″ shorter on each side than the longer pieces. For example, one door measures 31.5″ wide from side to side on the outside of the door casing. The widest header pieces are 33.5″ and the 1×4 sandwiched between them on top is 33″.

Here’s a side view of the trim pieces together.

click here for diy resource guide

Read More About Our DIY Home Updates

Favorite Behr White Paint Colors
Closet Door Ideas to Update Any Room
The Best Flooring for Every Room in Your Home
Trends in Cabinet Hardware


Which is Better? Wood or MDF?

One other consideration is the type of material for door trim. Through most of the house, we use MDF boards, because they are less expensive. We will use real wood for the trim in the bathroom, but otherwise, I can’t even tell much of a difference once it’s all painted. For the sake of efficiency, I painted stacks of MDF 1×4 before installation.

Pro tip: paint trim before it’s installed. We just do touch-ups afterward! It’s much easier this way.

painting the boards outside before installing

Once it was all painted (Ultra Pure White semi-gloss by Behr), Wyatt assembled the pieces for the tops of the doors and nailed them together. It’s much easier to do that first and then attach the whole thing to the wall. Here are some of the headers that I painted outside before installation:

trim for top of door casing on craftsman style door trim

Our Favorite Behr White Paint Colors

Here’s what the casing looks like before that piece is attached:

And here is the final product! I love how this looks with the Craftsman-style doors. We painted the doors in the same trim paint. The door trim is built to match on the inside and outside of each room, so it looks like this on both sides.

diy craftsman-style trim
Trim and doors painted Ultra Pure White by Behr | Walls are Silky White by Behr

Read More: 60+ Modern Black Door Hardware Ideas


How to Adjust Trim for Hinges and Strike Plates

Last week, I got a great question from a reader about accommodating for hinges with this kind of trim. Our old trim tapered in toward the door frame, so there was space for the hinges and strike plate. With this trim, we’ve just installed the casing as close to the hinges as possible, but you can see that it is slightly offset from the doorframe. If the trim was flush with the frame, we would have to notch out the casing around the hinges, which would be odd. Wyatt ripped this piece of door casing in order to fit in the corner, and it will be caulked and painted along both sides (where it meets the door frame and wall).

On the other side, this is what the casing looks like where the door latches shut. Even with the casing offset a tiny bit, the latch does scrape the trim very slightly, but not enough to bother us. However, if you want to avoid this issue, it’s possible to buy extended strike plates instead of the ones that come with your door handle kit.

This is what the strike plate looks like. An extended strike plate like this would cover the trim and avoid the paint-scraping issue. Looks like we’ll need to replace those strike plates at some point, anyway!

strike plate

Read More About Our DIY Home Updates

Favorite Behr White Paint Colors
Closet Door Ideas to Update Any Room
The Best Flooring for Every Room in Your Home
Trends in Cabinet Hardware


Free Guide to DIY

Final Craftsman-Style Door Trim with Painted Doors

This is the end of our hallway with completed trim. I love how the casing runs together where the three doors meet.

craftsman-style door trim
Trim and doors all painted Ultra Pure White by Behr | Walls are Silky White by Behr | diamond runner

Here’s a close-up of the corner where the pieces meet. For this continuous trim across three doors, Wyatt constructed the trim components in place (rather than building headers outside), due to the various custom angles. The 1×4 header pieces, running horizontally at the top of the doorframes, meet in a butt joint in each corner. The skinnier pieces that form the top and bottom of the headers are mitered together.

More About This Project:

Product Sources:
Similar interior doors
Pine 1×4 boards
MDF 1×4 boards
Pine 1×2 boards
MDF 7/16 x 1 1/4 boards
Schlage Latitude door levers
Black hinges

Rug – diamond runner in hallway

Paint Info:
Trim and doors are painted Ultra Pure White semi-gloss by Behr
Walls are Silky White eggshell by Behr

Favorite Behr White Paint Colors
Painting Tools and Tips
12 Tips for Using a HomeRight Paint Sprayer

Here are my coordinating black hardware picks:
12 Modern Black Door Hardware Ideas
6 Modern Black Cabinet Pulls

DIY Projects from List in Progress

list in progress projects

1 – 8 Upcycled DIY Craft Projects to Try
2 – Favorite Behr White Paint Colors
3 – Our New White Smart Thermostat
4 – How to Apply Gold Leaf to Glass Decor

Erin

Hi! I’m Erin, a Colorado-based home improvement blogger and lover of all things DIY. I aim to inspire creative folks to tackle home improvement with confidence and style. Read more here

free guide to diy

Share Your Thoughts:

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
27 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Mike Smith
Mike Smith
6 months ago

Hello!

For the header, how much did you overhang it on the sides from the vertical 1×4?

Thank you! 🙂

Alyssa
Alyssa
6 months ago

What size baseboards did you do then? The same 4”?

Debi
Debi
11 months ago

My question is – did you paint the doors the same as the trim? Ultra White Semi-gloss?

Rusty
Rusty
1 year ago

Did you trim room windows with same size trim?

Roger Craveiro
Roger Craveiro
1 year ago

big thanks for inspiring me to update our door and casing . Question about the mdf 1×4….don’t those have a slight round over along the facing edge? Just wondering what your thoughts are on that. It bugs me a bit that they are as sharp as the polar or pine.

Jerry
Jerry
11 months ago
Reply to  Erin

Hello. Is there any way you can provide a close up picture of that tight corner? I am in process of changing my hallway as well and ran into an issue where two doors meet in a very tight corner. I either want to do a header similar to yours or use rosettes but neither will fit.

Mike
Mike
1 year ago

What are the measurements of the top pieces as in how far they hang over. The 1×2 and 7/16 hang over at one length and the top 1×4 hangs over at a different length.
Looks like maybe 1 in and 1/2 in but might be smaller can’t really tell.

Jen
Jen
1 year ago

We are in the process of updating our trim and baseboards as well, but we’ve run into an issue making it work with the hinges and the latch plate thing. Because the wood is 1” thick, it seems we need to notch where these will go, but it doesn’t look right. Any suggestions? Thank you!

freebie

Your Freebie! 10 Easy DIY Ideas

Success! Please check your email.